Smelly Repellents January 14, 2002
Stink Bombs
A bad smell is enough to clear a room. Now the Department of Defense (DOD) is considering the possibility that a bad smell might be enough to clear an out-of-control crowd. Last week, it was announced that the DOD asked the Monell Chemical Senses Center in Philadelphia to make an "odor bomb" for use by the military to disperse unruly or even rioting crowds.

It's the kind of research that's not for the queasy, with scientists figuring that a cocktail of biological odors is most likely to offend all people, regardless of cultural background. With this in mind, researchers are making an odor bomb that will smell like rotting garbage, human waste, vomit, and burning hair. Foul as they sound, the advantage of using such odor bombs is that they offer a less aggressive means of crowd control than tear gas or pepper gas. People caught in their midst may feel nauseous but won't come to any real harm.

Similar tactics are sometimes used to control animal populations, too. In a curious story from Australia last week, wildlife officer Bruce Thomson describes unusual ways of keeping flying foxes away from lychee crops. Thomson plans to try odor bombs that smell of rotten eggs and ammonia to encourage the flying foxes to look for food elsewhere. He's even considering adding the odor of pythons, the natural enemy of the flying fox — if he can figure out a way to replicate that particular smell. "Maybe we could talk a perfume company into producing odor of python," Thomson joked in an article from Australia's Courier Mail.

In fact, an entire industry has been built on deterring animals through their sense of smell. The methods are environmentally- and creature-friendly because they don't involve traps or poisons. If you love deer but don't like them nibbling on your prized plants, try coyote urine in a box. Or if you want to keep geese from grazing on your lawn, sprinkle it with a concoction made from the bitter-tasting, smelly part of concord grapes — guaranteed to offend the discerning goose. Other methods include using castor oil to discombobulate moles, red pepper spray to irritate squirrels, and mustard to bother rabbits. Such methods offer non-harmful ways of discouraging critters from calling your yard home.

Making an Odor Bomb
The scientists working at the Monell Chemical Senses Center don't need to go to the original source to make the smell of burning hair or rotting garbage. They can chemically synthesize the odors. For example, a compound called scatole is the main component giving rise to the smell of human waste, and compounds called fatty acids give off a sour smell.

Living in the "Smellscape"
Odors offer a very effective way of influencing animal behavior because animals are very attuned to the smellscape. Smell is central to animals' identities and perceptions of each other. They use smells to communicate, find food, and protect territory. Watch a dog when he's out for a walk and you'll notice how much nose-wiggling and sniffing he does: He's interpreting his surroundings through smell. And of course there's the elaborate sniffing ritual that dogs go through when they encounter each other. When dogs sniff each other, it's the same as asking, "Where were you? What did you do today?"

Dogs can get this kind of information from smells because they live in a much richer smellscape than humans do, thanks to their turbo-powered noses (that's why they're so useful as rescue helpers and at finding illegal drug shipments). Bloodhounds, the champion sniffers, have about 220 million smell receptors in their noses, compared with humans' 5 million. Imagine the kind of "smell information" that a bloodhound receives as it sniffs the air!

The bloodhound's sensitive nose is likely to be accosted by the many animals that leave an unmistakable impression with the foul odors they emit. Certain animals kick up a stink to defend themselves; others use pungent liquids to mark territory and attract a mate. As smart dogs and their humans know, the most notorious odor-maker is the skunk.

Smelling Without a Nose
Many members of the animal kingdom don't need a nose in order to smell things. Flies have smell receptors in their feet and moths have them on their antennae. Can you imagine smelling things with your feet (instead of simply having smelly feet)?

Hunting in Disguise
Some hunters spray different kinds of scents on themselves to mask their natural body odors when out hunting. They use all kinds of scents, such as sage and vanilla, to blend in with their surroundings. Acorn scent can be used to attract deer (such scents are known as "lures"). Some hunters use powerful animal odors like skunk spray to block out all traces of human odor (these are "cover scents").

Skunk Science
Skunk spray smells terrible and it's tough to get rid of because it is an acidic yellow oil, making it very difficult to just rinse away. Other means need to be found (see sidebar). The skunk stores this noxious oil in two walnut-sized glands under the tail. When alarmed or attacked, the skunk lifts its tail and can spray the oil several feet — and whoever or whatever gets in the line of fire will reek for days.

The smell of skunk spray comes from the chemical compounds it contains, thiols. Thiols are also responsible for the odor of rotten eggs. Interestingly, thiol compounds are also found in great-tasting foods such as garlic and coffee — but in minute quantities compared with the thiol-loaded skunk spray. So, a little thiol contributes to making a good smell, but a lot of thiol is bad. This curious nuance has yet to be explained by scientists who study olfaction ("olfaction" is the name for the sense of smell).

  • You can find out more about the chemistry of skunk spray from William Wood's Web site. William Wood is a specialist in chemical ecology from Humboldt University.

For all its virtuosity, surprisingly, the skunk is not the champion of foul odors in the animal kingdom. Last year, the Discovery Channel's Nigel's Wild Wild World listed the top ten stinky animals and the skunk got second place. Here's the complete list but be warned — some of these animal behaviors are quite grisly!

    1. Tasmanian devil
    These aggressive creatures emit a foul odor when they get stressed out.

    2. Skunk
    As you've read, skunks spray a malodorous liquid as a means of self-defense.

The Tomato-Juice Myth
Covering your unfortunate skunk-annointed pet in tomato juice does not get rid of the skunk odor. It merely masks it. If you're convinced that the tomato juice really is eliminating the skunk odor, it's because you're suffering from "olfactory fatigue": a short amount of time of inhaling the skunk smell, your nose becomes immune to it. (This phenomenon explains why people can't smell their own perfume and smokers don't realize they smell like cigarettes.)

How do you rid your pet of the foul skunk smell? Place all of the following in a tub of water and bathe your pet for five minutes.

1 quart of 3% hydrogen peroxide
1/4 cup baking soda
1 teaspoon liquid detergent

After bathing, rinse your pet with water. Then repeat if necessary. This recipe comes from William Wood's skunk Web site.

Please note: For safety reasons, discard any unused mixture. Do not store it.

    3. Hyena
    Hyenas mark their territory with a smelly substance secreted from anal glands and glands between their toes.

    4. Turkey vulture
    When threatened, these large birds may vomit as a defensive maneuver. Also, when they're hot, they may excrete on their own legs to cool themselves. It sounds awful, but it works!

    5. Wolverine
    These predators have scent glands that produce a strong, musk-like odor for marking territory.

    6. Musk ox
    These animals produce urine that smells pungent enough to make your eyes water. They use it for marking territory, an important part of the mating process.

    7. Stinkbug
    Some of these bugs are pests, damaging crops such as tomatoes and rice. One type of stinkbug, T. Papillosa, can "spit" its secretions a distance of 6-12 inches — quite an achievement for a small bug.

    8. Beaver
    These cute dam-builders have scent glands near the anus that produce a musky liquid called "castoreum." The liquid is thought to play a part in attracting a mate.

    9. Fox
    Red foxes have scent glands near the anus and in the tail. The secretions smell like skunk spray and are used for marking territory. Their urine also has a strong, "skunky" odor.

    10. Porcupine
    Porcupines exhibit a very smelly behavior. Before mating, the male porcupine showers the female with urine. If she does not object, it shows that she is ready to mate.

More Links
The Tasmanian devil out-stinks all other animals. Listen to a fascinating radio program about the Tasmanian devil from National Geographic and National Public Radio.

Find out more about the giggling hyena, number 3 on the smelliest creatures list.

Here is further information about the turkey vulture, number 4 on the list.

Sniffer dogs earn a living from their sense of smell. Read about how sniffer dogs have helped with efforts related to the September 11th attacks from the Pet News Service.

The animal odor top ten is certainly competitive — and somewhat gross. After reading all these stories of foul odors, you may want to go and pick up some fresh-cut flowers or make yourself a cup of hot chocolate to savor some good aromas. While you're enjoying that hot chocolate, here are some odoriferous questions for you to consider:

  • Can you think of some ways in which you depend on your sense of smell? (Consider food and taste.)
  • How do we use references to smell in everyday speech? For example, "Wake up and smell the coffee" or "Smells like trouble." Can you think of other examples?
  • Helen Keller said, "Smell is a potent wizard that transports you across thousands of miles and all the years you have lived." Do you think humans use their sense of smell as much as they could? Do you think humans depend more on one sense as they interpret their environment? How do the senses work together?

We'll answer some of these questions in next week's article on odors and how we smell them — "What the Nose Knows."

Related Activities
Graham's Law
Learn how odors are spread around a room in this simulation of gas diffusion (for high school students).
A Whiff of the Future
Read about manufacturing smells and aromatherapy in this article from the Riverdeep archive.